Popkin develops a model of rational peasant behavior and shows how village procedures result from. The political economy of rural society in vietnam 1st edition by popkin, samuel l. The rational peasant the political economy of rural society. Brewer princeton unction, n in this book, popkins basic concern is to refute the explanations for peasant rebellions put for ward by james c. Moral economy of the peasant umich university of michigan. These assumptions have drawn attention to different features of villages and patronclient ties and have led to questions about the quality of welfare and insurance embedded in both villages and vertical patronclient ties. Popkin wrote a book called the rational peasant, the political economy of rural society in vietnam, which in many ways paralleled scotts. Popkin builds on olsons argument in the rational peasant. This political economy view of peasant behavior stands in contrast to the model of a distinctive peasant moral economy in which the village community is primarily responsible for ensuring the welfare of. The fear of food shortages, he argues persuasively, explains many otherwise puzzling technical, social, and moral arrangements in peasant society, such as resistance to innovation, the desire to own land even at some cost in terms of income, relationships with other. This political economy view of peasant behavior stands. James scotts and samuel popkin s theories must undergo the test of historical facts. Having not worked in exactly the same fields south or central vietnam or on the same periods colonial or postcolonial eras, both, scott and popkin have generalized their own experiences.
The first two terms were used by samuel popkin in his book the rational peasant to distinguish his own perspective on vietnam, which he calls political economy, from the perspective he calls moral economy, 6enter for research on social organization, university of michigan. Like the earlier formalist reaction to substantivism, popkin sought to reemphasize the importance of the calculating peasant. In public choice and rural development, edited by cliff s. Extending olson 1971s framework to peasant collective action in vietnam a. Moral economists believe that peasant protest is a result of falling below a subsistence level shortrun security, or the loss of traditional institutions that provided for peasant welfare longterm. The moral economy of the peasant book pdf download. Subsistence and rebellion in southeast asia yale, 1976. The political economy of rural society in vietnam berkeley. University of california press, 1979, chapters 1and 2.
Can rational choice theory explain participation that puts. Against the idea that peasants are economically rational agents who decide about political participation based on a narrowly defined costbenefit analysis, scott argues for a more complex political psychology incorporating socially. The political economy of rural society in vietnam, chapters 1, 2, 6 read closely, chapters 3, 4, 5 read more quickly daniel little, the moral economy debate, in understanding peasant china yale, 1989, pp. Dilemma, paradox, and irony in peasant collective action, world politics 46, no. Popkin has played a role in the development of rational choice theory within political science. So the theory of rational choice allows us to understand their behavior and the collective patterns that ensue. Popkin born june 9, 1942 is a noted political scientist who teaches at the university of california, san diego. Popkin dengan bukunya the rational peasant mengambil kasus kehidupan petani di vietnam, sedangkan james scott dalam bukunya the moral economy of. In the rational peasant, popkin attempts to discredit the. I shall discuss both the widelyaccepted interpretation of this impact, the moral economy. Popkin dengan bukunya the rational peasant mengambil kasus kehidupan petani di vietnam, sedangkan james scott dalam bukunya the moral economy of the peasant, banyak membicarakan kasus di birma. Popkin develops a model of rational peasant behavior and shows how village procedures.
Resources and the information problem in rebel recruitment. Popkin develops a model of rational peasant behavior and shows how village procedures result from the selfinterested interactions of peasants. The rational peasant samuel l popkin popkin develops a model of rational peasant behavior and shows how village procedures result from the selfinterested interactions of peasants. University of california, san diego political science 200a. James scotts and samuel popkins theories must undergo the test of historical facts. Social theory and peasant revolution in vietnam and guatemala. Collective action requires more than consensus or even intensity of need. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Pdf popkin the reasoning voter diana soraia academia. This, in turn, has demonstrated that there is more potential value to. Charles tilly, the politics of collective violence cambridge up, 2003, chs 1, 3, and 10. In this book, popkins basic concern is to refute the explanations.
In the rational peasant, popkin attempts to discredit the common assumption of moral economy page. Perdebatan samuel popkin dan james scott tentang petani di asia tenggara sudah banyak dibicarakan orang. Some lineage sections specialize in one herd animal or another. The political economy of rural society in vietnam, berkeley, university of california press, 1979 4 of 17. Scott places the critical problem of the peasant householdsubsistenceat the center of this study. Program in political science the graduate center, the. Popkin has also written extensively on peasant society with particular reference to east and southeast asia, and on the politics of local government.
Their combined citations are counted only for the first article. His theory is based on the figure of a hyper rational peasant that bases his decision to join or not a rebellion uniquely on a costbenefit analysis. This political economy view of peasant behavior stands in contrast to the model of a distinctive. Rebellion and subsistence in southeastasia new haven. The political economy of rural society in vietnam is the prime example. Candidate ebok samuel l popkin 9780199922086 bokus. The political economy of rural society in vietnam university of california press 1979. Peasants are rational agents, making calculating decisions about their interests and choices. Summary short popkin develops a model of rational peasant. Samuel popkin, political entrepreneurs and peasant movements in vietnam, in michael taylor, ed. Popkin born june 9, 1942 is a political scientist who teaches at the university of california, san diego. Intense or shared grievances wont solve the collective action problem.
Bookmark file pdf the rational peasant the political economy of rural society in vietnam. This political economy view of peasant behavior stands in contrast to the model of a distinctive peasan. The political economy of rural society in vietnam, california, 1979 5 james c. The political economy of rural society in vietnam by samuel l. Request an exam or desk copy recommend to your library pdf rightslink. The rational peasant the political economy of peasant society samuel popkin this essay concerns the impact of colonialism, the expansion of markets, and the formation of central states on peasant society. The rational peasant samuel popkin, the rational peasant peasants are rational agents, making calculating decisions about their interests and choices. Your use of the jstor archive indicates your acceptance of. Popkins political economy approach holds that peasants are rational.
Obrien and lianjiang li, rightful resistance in rural china cambridge, 2006 4 samuel popkin, the rational peasant. This essay concerns the impact of colonialism, the expansion of. University of california, san diego foundations of. The rational peasant the political economy of rural.
The data analysis used is qualitative hermeneutical analysis using moral economic theory james scoot and rational farmer samuel popkin. Popkin did research in south vietnamese villages for two years during the war studying local warfare, and is the author of the rational peasant. Comparative politics reading list schar school of policy. The fear of food shortages, he argues persuasively, explains many otherwise puzzling technical, social, and moral arrangements in peasant society, such as resistance to innovation, the desire to own land even at some cost in terms of income, relationships. Samuel popkin was the first to address this question in the context of rebellion. I have made assumptions about individual behavior diverging from those of the moral economists. Originally conceived to be a reflection on the vietnam revolution, the book introduces the term political economy as a new theory of peasant behavior. The rational peasant is published three years after james c. The result of the research shows that the low production of. The rational peasant by popkin, samuel l author paperback 1979 samuel l popkin on. Popkin university of california press, 1979, 306 pp. The rational peasant download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Pdf bringing the moral economy back in to the study of 21st. This political economy view of peasant behavior stands in contrast to the model of a distinctive peasant moral economy in which the village community is primarily responsible for ensuring the welfare of its members.
974 1040 784 904 1100 1066 1284 82 1244 1336 1399 1110 1289 939 1205 431 28 20 81 27 1223 1496 311 9 453 74 22 959 1257 1483 187 654 1303 267 776 343 1223 136 1127 905 1497